Labels such as "gifted," "average," or "deficient" that are placed on students by schools

Search databasePMCAll DatabasesAssemblyBiocollectionsBioProjectBioSampleBioSystemsBooksClinVarConserved DomainsdbGaPdbVarGeneGenomeGEO DataSetsGEO ProfilesGTRHomoloGeneIdentical Protein Web CatalogNucleotideOMIMPMCPopSetProteinProtein ClustersProtein Family ModelsPubChem BioAssayPubChem CompoundPubChem SubstancePubMedSNPSRAStructureTaxonomyToolKitToolKitAllToolKitBookgh

Diagnostic Labels, Stigma, and also Participation in Research Related to Dementia and also Mild Cognitive Impairment
Dr. Linda Garand also, PhD, GCNS-BC, Assistant Professor, Dr. Jennifer H. Lingler, PhD, RN, FNP, Assistant Professor, Dr. Kyaien O. Conner, PhD, LSW, MPH, Postdoctdental Fellow, and Dr. Mary Amanda Dew, PhD, Professor

Dr. Linda Garand

Health and Community Systems Department, The University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Dr. Jennifer H. Lingler

Health and Community Solution Department, The University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Dr. Kyaien O. Conner

Department of Psychiatry, The University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Dr. Mary Amanda Dew

Departments of Psychiaattempt, Psychology, Epidemiology, and Biostatistics, The University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Dr. Linda Garand, Health and Community Solution Department, The College of Pittsburgh School of Nursing, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania;
Address correspondence to Linda Garand also, PhD, GCNS-BC, Assistant Professor, Health and also Community Equipment Department, The College of Pittsburgh School of Nursing, 415 Victoria Building, 3500 Victoria Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15261; ude.ttip

Health treatment experts use diagnostic labels to classify people for both treatment and also research study functions. Despite their clear benefits, diagnostic labels likewise serve as cues that activate stigma and stereoforms. Stigma linked through the diagnostic labels of dementia and mild cognitive impairment (MCI) have the right to have actually a far-reaching and negative affect on interindividual relationships, interactions through the health and wellness care area, perspectives about service utilization, and also participation in clinical study. The impact of stigma additionally extends to the household caregivers of individuals bearing such labels. In this write-up, we use examples from our investigations of individuals via dementia or MCI and also their household caregivers to examine the influence of labeling and stigma on clinical study participation. We likewise discuss how stigma have the right to influence countless aspects of the nursing study process. Strategies are presented for addressing stigma-associated barriers to participation in clinical study on dementia and also MCI.

You watching: Labels such as "gifted," "average," or "deficient" that are placed on students by schools

Across the life span, stigma linked through diagnostic labels have the right to interfere through adequate provision of care, patients" willingness to look for care, household members" experience of living through the patient, and also both patients" and families" willingness to participate in research linked through the disease or disorder. In this short article, we check out the affect of labeling and stigma on clinical research participation among older adults through or at risk for dementia and also their family caregivers. As a structure, we provide background indevelopment on dementia and mild cognitive special needs (MCI). We then examine the nature of stigma connected via diagnostic labels of neuropsychiatric illness in basic (encompassing practical psychiatric illnesses such as mood disorders, as well as problems via organic etiologies) and define evidence concerning the stigma knowledgeable by people who have actually been diagnosed through dementia. Using examples from our own research, we explore just how stigma can affect the nursing research procedure via older adults who have actually a diagnostic label of either dementia or MCI and their family members caregivers. We likewise imply strategies to diminish the negative affect of stigma on clinical research via these patients and their household caregivers.


Gerontological nurse investigators must be cognizant of the stigma connected via diagnostic labels regarded dementia or milder forms of cognitive impairment, as these problems are highly widespread among older adults. Current estimates imply that 5.2 million people in the USA have Alzheimer"s illness or another create of dementia, and also projections indicate as many kind of as 16 million older Americans will certainly be affected by dementia by mid-century (Alzheimer"s Association, 2008b). The numbers likewise reflect a prospering demand also for efficient educational and support programs for family caregivers as they administer care and assistance to the impfinishing wave of world through dementia (Institute of Medicine, 2008; National Institute of Nursing Research, 2006). Because of this, to administer crucial research study and build reliable treatment programs, investigators need to be prepared to attend to and also attempt to overcome issues pertained to labeling and also stigma among the patient and also household populations impacted by dementia or MCI.

Dementia and MCI

Both dementia and MCI are crucial targets for avoidance and treatment research study. Dementia is a prevalent syndrome among older adults and also is linked with a number of underlying condition pathologies (e.g., Alzheimer"s condition, vascular dementia, Lewy body dementia). The pathological procedures linked through Alzheimer"s condition and also other kinds of dementia are progressive, bring about ongoing destruction of cognitive, behavior, and also social functioning over time. To receive a diagnosis of dementia, an individual need to show cognitive deficits that involve both memory impairments and a disturbance in at least one other location of cognition (e.g., aphasia, apraxia, agnosia) and also a disturbance in functioning (Amerideserve to Psychiatric Association , 2000). Such practical deterioration outcomes in extensive individual suffering and also financial strain for influenced individuals and also their household members.

The insidious progression of symptom oncollection in dementia regularly consists of a subsyndromal phase throughout which an individual expresses symptoms of, but does not fulfill diagnostic criteria for, dementia (Petersen, 2001). Referred to as MCI, this subsyndromal duration is linked through memory deficits or various other mild cognitive dysattribute through little or no result on day-to-day functioning (Winblad et al., 2004). Research indicates that, depending on the sampling strategy and also operational interpretation of MCI provided, yearly convariation rates to dementia vary from 10% to 15% per year, compared through 1% to 7% per year for individuals who carry out not have actually MCI (Petersen et al., 1999). Due to the fact that MCI is a far-from-perfect predictor of dementia (Bruscoli & Loverock, 2004), it is primarily given as a “research” diagnosis rather than for functions of clinical care. A diagnostic label of MCI permits clinical researchers to recognize individuals eligible for clinical trials testing the effectiveness of strategies to proccasion or delay the onset of dementia.

Diagnostic Labels

Using current nosologies, health and wellness care experts assign diagnostic labels to classify people for both treatment and study purposes. Diagnostic labels allow clinicians and also researchers to assume that all members of a team are generally homogeneous in the underlying nature of the condition, regardless of whether tright here is some varicapability in the presentation of symptoms or scenarios neighboring illness onset. In other words, diagnostic labels differentiate patient groups by a collection of definable limits (APA, 2000). Hence, diagnostic labels serve a number of objectives. First, they provide an effective way for clinicians and also researchers to understand a large amount of indevelopment (Frances, First, Pincus, Widiger, & Davis, 1990; Rosch & Mueller, 1978). They additionally provide a convenient implies for describing patients that has the presentation of symptoms and may indicate the expected course and also prognosis. Lastly, diagnostic labels might imply etiology as well as suggest the way towards particular interventions that may proccasion or ameliorate the after-effects of the condition (Corrigan, 2007).

Despite the benefits of diagnostic labels, such labels regularly serve as cues to signal stereoforms. The negative after-effects of labeling appear to aclimb with 2 social psychological processes. First, once an individual is diagnosed via a neuropsychiatric disorder, social principles connected via those via psychological condition (e.g., inknowledgeable, dangerous) end up being personally relevant and foster negative feelings of self. Second, these personally relevant social meanings transform right into expectations that others will disapprove them, and also these expectations deserve to cause protective habits aimed at preventing that rejection (Link, 1987; Link, Cullen, Struening, Shrout, & Dohrenwfinish, 1989). One such behavior might be reluctance to learn about or participate in research studies in an initiative to stop the stigma connected via the diagnostic labels. Below, we testimonial the principle of stigma and also comment on exactly how behavior manifestations of stigma influence the stays of individuals diagnosed with dementia.


In Goffman"s (1963) seminal work-related, he supplied the term stigma to refer to “an attribute that is deeply discrediting within a social interaction” (p. 3). Individuals possessing such an attribute are various from others in methods that are undesired and also shameful. The stigmatized individual is “reduced…from a totality and also usual person to a tainted, discounted one” (Goffmale, 1963, p. 3). Stigmas are frequently the features that, once oboffered by a majority group member, may result in labeling, stereotyping, separation, condition loss, and also discrimicountry (Link & Phelan, 2001). Labeling and stereokeying involve the acknowledgment of differences and the assignment of social salience to those distinctions. In the context of condition, labeling is the acknowledgment that a perboy via a specific diagnosis differs from the norm in means that have actually social significance. Stereoinputting is the assignment of negative attributions to these socially salient differences (i.e., the perception that the distinctions are undesirable). Separation occurs once the reactions of others to these distinctions cause a pronounced sense of “otherness” or “felt stigma” (Green, Davis, Karshmer, Marsh, & Straight, 2005) (i.e., the individual"s personal awareness that others are dealing with him or her in a different way as a result of some individual attribute).

Status loss and also discrimination occur once stigma interferes with an individual"s capacity to participate completely in the social and also financial life of his or her area. In these scenarios of “enacted stigma” (Eco-friendly et al., 2005), there is a lot of most likely a power differential favoring those without the trait over those who have it. Thus, the stigmatization of individuals with a details disease or problem is a facility process entailing the labeling of individual differences, the negative review of those differences by others, others" adverse reactions, and negative social and emotional outcomes for the affected individual (Eco-friendly et al., 2005).

In addition to public stigma, human being with particular diagnostic labels may additionally experience self-stigma, or an internalization of the stereoforms held by the basic public (Corrigan, 2007). This internalized or self-stigma might deter people from seeking therapy and social solutions, also once the opportunities are accessible, simply to avoid the stigma linked through that label. Research in this location suggests that people might pick not to look for expert aid as a means of protecting themselves from embarrassment and feelings of inferiority or incompetence (Nadler, 1990; Wills & DePaulo, 1991). Further, stigma often tends “to spreview from the stigmatized individual to his/her cshed connections” (Goffman, 1963, p. 30). Research in this area says that both main caregivers and also various other household members suffer stigma and frequently endure boosted emotional dianxiety and social isolation (MacRae, 1999).

See more: Organizational Behavior Flashcards

Research Related to Stigma and The Dementia Label

The stigma and also discrimination attached to a diagnostic label of dementia are strongly connected through experiencing, discapability, and financial losses (Graham et al., 2003). Several aspects of this stigmatization are explained in the literary works. Dementia is regularly mistaken as a organic component of aging (Graham et al., 2003; Lebowitz & Niederehe, 1992). When dementia is taken into consideration an unpreferable herbal process, quite than a pathological problem, component of the stigma linked with it might incorporate the idea that the problem is untreatable. To the level that patients, their households, and the basic public mistakenly believe that therapy is not helpful, societal mandays to finance treatment or reimburse treatment costs will alleviate consumers" access to sources and avenues for treatment and related social solutions. In certain instances, the dementia diagnosis is offered to exclude individuals from some forms of health care, such as inpatient treatment or nursing home treatment (other than on dementia-particular units) (Graham et al., 2003). A consequent incapacity or faitempt to obtain treatment reinpressures damaging fads of low self-esteem, isolation, and hopelessness (Graham et al., 2003).

Specific symptoms seen in some people through dementia (e.g., disturbed thinking and behavior, negative self-treatment, incontinence) are powertotally stigmatizing in the community and also in wellness treatment settings. Individuals through dementia are often perceived as having bit to no quality of life or capacity for pleasure. Thus, individual choices and also cultural or spiritual beliefs might be ignored (Graham et al., 2003). Evidence says that stigma leads world to stop socializing via, employing, working with, renting to, or living close to individuals via dementia (Graham et al., 2003). A survey of 1,000 participants exemplifies this point: 81% of respondents believed they would certainly be looked upon or treated differently if others knew they were diagnosed via dementia (Crisp, Gelder, Rix, Meltzer, & Rowlands, 2000).

Research mirrors that stigma and discrimination extfinish to family members caregivers of individuals with dementia (Benbow & Reynolds, 2000; Jolley & Benbow, 2000). For example, their loved one"s symptoms (e.g., negative self-care, incontinence) are regularly related to as evidence of overlook (Graham et al., 2003). Furthermore, to the extent that people attempt to stop social interactions via patients with dementia, those patients" family members caregivers may be inadvertently excluded too. Therefore, for example, once one member of a married couple is stigmatized, the spouse is most likely to endure the results as well.

Individuals with dementia have themselves described their experiences with stigma and also other social transforms lugged around by the diagnostic label of dementia. For instance, a study exploring responses of assistance group members via early-phase dementia discovered the the majority of frequently voiced themes were pertains to around the nature of the condition and the diagnostic process, awareness of the stigma attached to a diagnosis of dementia, and impacts of the diagnosis and also the disease on relationships through families and friends (Yale, 1995). These issues were of specific worry bereason participants wanted to save their resides full and also coherent for as long as possible, and also prepare appropriately for the future (Yale, 1995).

The Alzheimer"s Association (2008b) analyzed dialogues of more than 300 human being living through early-phase Alzheimer"s disease at nationwide town hall meetings and online tvery own meetings organized online at the Alzheimer"s Association Net website. In this study, participants mutual their experiences and also perspectives on exactly how they wish to be regarded, respected, engaged, and treated by health experts, researchers, and also the general public. Common themes determined by participants had stigma connected with a diagnostic label of Alzheimer"s condition and also its impact on relationships, dissatisfying interactions with the health and wellness care community, uncertainty around availcapability of assistance services, sources of significant worry in daily life, and also a desire to remain associated and make a difference. An overriding design template that arised in the tvery own hall meetings was that world via early-phase Alzheimer"s illness are mistaken because of myths and misconceptions around the condition and that misexpertise leads to a leading negative stigma connected with having actually the problem (Alzheimer"s Association, 2008a).

Research Related to Stigma and The MCI Label

Considerably less is recognized about patients" and family members members" perceptions of any kind of stigma associated with the label of MCI. The literary works confirms confusion related to the MCI diagnosis (Alzheimer"s Association, 2008a; Frank et al., 2006; Whitehouse & Moody, 2006). In an effort to much better understand also the experience of living through MCI, Lingler et al. (2006) used qualitative approaches to study exactly how people “make sense” of the fact that they had received a research study diagnosis of MCI. Findings indicated that assigning meaning to the diagnosis was a fundamental facet of living through the diagnosis just one of examine participants. According to Goffguy (1963), assigning interpretation to a diagnostic label requires the acknowledgment that the perkid via the label differs in some method from the basic public. In the Lingler et al. (2006) examine, the definition participants assigned to their diagnoses varied widely depending upon their expectations concerned normal aging, personal endure via dementia, and concurrent wellness problems. For instance, an individual that regarded memory loss as an expected component of the aging procedure was reasonably unaffected by the MCI label, stating, “It"s just a matter of putting a name on the problem I was aware of” (Lingler et al., 2006, p. 796). By contrast, those that regarded MCI as a definite precursor to Alzheimer"s disease voiced significant ditension.

Frank et al. (2006) likewise examined responses to receiving a research diagnosis of MCI or beforehand dementia among a sample of patients and also their family caregivers. Emerging themes included uncertainty of the diagnosis, skill loss, transforms in social and also family members roles, embarrassment and shame, emotionality, insight right into their condition, and also burden. Affected people reported frustration with recognized memory problems, diminimelted self-confidence, fear of embarrassment, concerns around transforming family roles because of progressively worsening cognitive special needs, and also stress.

While research suggests that diagnostic labels pertaining to dementia and cognitive handicap are connected through stigma, it also indicates that a label of dementia or MCI can evoke sympathy and also helping actions in some situations. This has actually been oboffered for various other conditions (Ray, Raciti, & MacLean, 1992) and may outcome from differential attributions of duty (Kroska & Harkness, 2006). For example, Weiner, Perry, and also Magnuschild (1988) compared research participants" perceptions of people with problems for which their very own behavior was thought to be a contributory variable (i.e., AIDS and also obesity) through those of people believed to have actually little bit or no function in the oncollection of their problem (i.e., Parkinson"s condition and multiple sclerosis). Participants reported considerably greater pity, much less anger, and also more help-offering emotional responses to the last patient team (Weiner et al., 1988). In brief, stigma and also perceptions of blame might be eradicated in the visibility of certain clinical diagnoses, making it less likely the patient will certainly be criticized or rejected for deviant actions and even more most likely he or she will obtain help (Ray et al., 1992). The provision of appropriate disease labels, especially once the labels insinuate a disease process, might result in clear benefits for patients, such as seeking and receiving correct treatment and support solutions. Therefore, as public awareness rises about of the organic etiology of dementia and milder levels of cognitive impairment—or if public expertise boosts regarding the benefits of therapy for dementia—we could intend that stigma linked with these problems would be lessened.

See more: Recognized Neuronal Circuit Patterns Include All Of The Following Except

Tright here is already some proof that people via cognitive disability can be perceived with compassion by the general public. For example, in a examine from Israel, Werner and Davidboy (2004) asked participants to check out vignettes describing people through dementia. The investigators found that the vignettes elicited more positive (compassion and concern) than negative (rejection, disgust, anger, irritation, and also dismay) reactions, particularly among woguys. In a study by Wadley and Haley (2001), participants responded to vignettes describing “your mother” or “your father” exhibiting habits constant via a diagnosis of dementia, major depression, or no label at all (e.g., irritcapability, forgetfulness, social withdrawal). Results confirmed that the diagnostic label of Alzheimer"s disease—and to a lesser degree the significant depression label—developed more sympathy toward the parent, much less blame, and also higher willingness to aid. Although responding to vignettes might differ from responses in actual encounters via those with dementia, these studies indicate that the provision of diagnostic labels may, under some scenarios, facilitate compassionate attitudes and amplified caregiving towards older adults.