Explain why science can answer some questions but not others

There comes a time for every graduate student pursuing a doctorate in approach (PhD) when they should narrowhead dvery own their research study interests and also make a commitment to a dissertation topic. Usually, they’ve had actually a basic feeling of the area in which they’re working, they’ve read an extrasimple number of research documents and publications on their topic (so they understand wbelow the understanding gaps, or locations of ignorance are to be found) and they’re on the cusp of advancing from student to a much more mature standing we contact a candidate. Maarten van Doorn just publiburned an write-up that consisted of a few paragraphs around autonomy, and it reminded me that he might be at or close to this phase.

You watching: Explain why science can answer some questions but not others

Tbelow are generally 2 ideologies for formalizing or structuring their research: 1) hypotheses, 2) research study inquiries. They are not mutually exclusive, however a lot of students will either select one or the other. The hypotheses approach is even more popular in engineering (my field) and also physical scientific researches, which lend themselves to experimental falsification. The ideal hypotheses are conjectures, or guesses, about the relationship in between independent and also dependent variables. Therefore, they are declared in a means that says the experiment that might falsify them. (If it can’t be falsified by speculative examination, it’s not a hypothesis. It’s just a crackpot idea).

Many of the students I work-related through begin with the study question method, at least at initially. Its seems simpler or less formal, yet the fact is that just the wrong inquiries come easily. Asking the right question takes exercise.

Often, that practice comes in the develop of a conversation that sounds somepoint favor this:

Student: Thank you for meeting via me now Dr. Seager! I want you to know that I’ve decided on my research question! I’m going to examine, “Why is the sky blue?”

Me: That’s wrong.

Student: Wait, what? How deserve to a question be wrong? I thought just answers deserve to be wrong?

Me: Of course inquiries deserve to be wrong. Your question is wrong.

Student: What’s wrong through it?

Me: As a doctoral student, your job is to usage science to create new knowledge, and also science is not equipped to answer “Why?” concerns.

Student: But that’s precisely what scientific research is meant to do! Aren’t we trying to explain things as in, A causes B reasons C and so that’s why we have C?

Me: No. It is true that science investientrances causal chains, favor A — >B — >C, yet that’s not the answer to a “Why?” question. It’s the answer to a “How?” question. Science does not answer why.

Me (again): For example, intend that your research study question was restated as, “How is the skies blue?” then we could create version of light diffractivity and we can display just how the environment splits sunlight into different spectral components, with these wavelengths going in this direction and also those wavelengths going in that directions and also we can say, “Well, the sky is not always blue, yet these are the mechanisms that run on sunlight and also the conditions under which the sky is blue, or red, or orange, or green, or gray or babsence.”



Picture by Lightscape on Unsplash

Student: That’s unsatisfying. I ended up being a PhD student because I wanted to understand why things are the method they are..

Me: Then you will be sodepend disappointed by your studies

Me (continuing): Science is exceptionally, incredibly great at answering “What?” questions, such as “What are the colors of the sky?”

And science is pretty good at answering the “How?” inquiries, such as, “How did these colors acquire here?” but scientific research is unable to answer “Why is tbelow a sky? Why perform we have actually color?” We deserve to explain gravity and thermodynamics and how the environment developed, however we cannot say why it all exists.

Student: But science does defines gravity! And it defines why the planets orlittle the sun, and also the setting clings to the earth!

Me: No. Science answers like, “What is the universal gravitational continuous that predicts the activity of the planets roughly the sun?” It does not answer, “Why is this the gravitational constant, rather than some other?” or “Why is the speed of light what it is?”

Science only answers “What is the rate of light?” and also “How does the speed of light relate to our perception of color?”

It does not tell us why.

Student: That contradicts every little thing that I’ve been told in my life up to now!

Me: Congratulations. You’re on your way to completing your research studies.

Student: When I was a kid, my parents offered to read me the Just So Stories by Rudyard Kipling, choose “How the Elephant Got its Trunk” and also stuff prefer that. I used to love the stories. But then I uncovered that they weren’t true. It was choose Santa Claus! My parents had been entertaining me with all these lies! That’s as soon as I knew I wanted to study science, so I can understand also the truth of things.

See more: Our Emotions Influence What We Recognize Or Screen Out., Access To This Page Has Been Denied

Me: Well, you will certainly have to give up certain childish misconceptions about scientific research to become a scientist. First, Santa Claus is actual. Second, Kipling’s stories are a wonderful arrival to Darwin’s concept of natural selection. It’s even more scientific than you think. Notice that Kipling never created a story called, “Why the Tiger has actually Stripes,” he always titles his stories “How…”?

Student: How can Santa Claus be real?

Me. The evidence is pretty convincing. The theory of Santa Claus predicts presents will appear under a certain type of tree, on a particular hour, at a particular day. And the experimental results are continuous via this concept. Tright here the presents are, under the trees. Additionally, they are marked, “from Santa Claus.” I have actually countless information points on this one, and also the experiment is replicated with good success annually.

Student: But it’s the paleas that put the presents under the tree! Not some obese, bearded old man through flying reindeer!

Me. Then we shall revise our design to accord via the evidence and also call the parents, “Santa Claus.” Anybody through a desire to offer anonymous gifts deserve to be Santa. You deserve to be Santa, because Santa is a theoretical symbol for generosity — for obtaining the feeling of giving a gift without any type of expectation of reciprocity. Discard the flying reindeer, yet keep the principle and you’ll watch that Santa is real, and also essential to helping us understand human actions and emotions.

Student: Why perform we have this concept called Santa Claus?

Me: I don’t know. I’m a scientist. I don’t answer “Why?” concerns. That’s a various profession.

Student: I believed I was making progression, currently I’m simply confused.

Me: This form of confusion is progress. If you want to answer “Why?” concerns, then you require a mechanism of belief. I think it was Feynman who said, “Religion is a culture of faith; scientific research is a society of doubt.

Science just moves forward by finding out things that are not true — by falsification.

Industry, company, and also a lot of various other professions do not concern themselves through what is true or false. They worry themselves via what works.

Science is about finding out falsehoods. Religion is around having actually confidence in the idea that some points are true.

You would perform well to confine your dissertation to concerns of “What?” and “How?” and leave the “Why?” inquiries to story-tellers and also prophets.

Students: That’s it? Just adjust my question words?

Me: Getting the question best is the a lot of important point that a Doctor of Philosophy must have the ability to to perform.

See more: Access To This Page Has Been Denied

Too frequently, we underestimate the prestige of knowledge our question. When you gain lost in your search for knowledge, ask yourself, “What question was I trying to answer?” and check out if that helps you uncover your way again.